Andy Serkis is no stranger to Tolkien’s world. His groundbreaking performance as Gollum/Smeagol in Peter Jackson’s film trilogies permanently altered the landscape of cinema and performance capture. Following his acclaimed, marathon recordings of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings , tackle-reading The Silmarillion was the logical, ultimate frontier.
Serkis brings a dramatic, high-energy approach to Tolkien’s foundational myths. Unlike the more traditional, scholarly reading by Martin Shaw (the previous standard), Serkis uses: Distinct Character Voices:
: In the tragic story of Túrin Turambar, Serkis delivers a raw, Shakespearean performance that perfectly conveys a family trapped under a dark, inescapable curse.
Aesthetic and cultural implications
The Guardian’s review noted that Serkis brings "customary clarity, gravitas and an impressive range of voices to Tolkien’s often dense prose". In interviews, Serkis explained that he approaches the creation mythology with a sense of breath and space. The measured cadence, the hushed reverence for the moment Eä is sung into being, and the sudden crescendo of power for the discord of Melkor (Morgoth) create a cinematic audio soundscape that exists solely in the listener’s imagination. It is as if a classical thespian is telling you the most important story ever told.
Download or stream The Silmarillion by J. R. R. Tolkien. Get 50% off this audiobook at the AudiobooksNow online audio book store and download or stream it right to your computer, smartphone or tablet.
published a comprehensive review of the Andy Serkis-narrated The Silmarillion audiobook titled silmarillion audiobook andy serkis
Ultimately, both versions are masterpieces in their own right. Shaw’s version is the authoritative, historical chronicle, while Serkis’s version is the immersive, dramatic epic.
His dedication to elvish and dwarvish pronunciation makes the text flow more naturally, helping listeners connect to the lyrical language of the First Age. Conclusion
This public link is valid for 7 days and shares a thread, including any personal information you added. This link or copies made by others cannot be deleted. If you share with third parties, their policies apply. Can’t copy the link right now. Try again later. Andy Serkis is no stranger to Tolkien’s world
I can provide the exact tips or platform comparisons you need to get started. Share public link
The stories include the legend of the creation of Eä, the world taking in Valinor, Beleriand, the island of Númenor and Middle-earth, and a history of events leading up to the First Age. Morgoth, the first Dark Lord, is at war with the High Elves, who are intent on recovering the Silmarils, three gemstones stolen by Morgoth that contain the light that illuminates Middle-earth. For decades, readers were warned that while it is the loftiest peak of high fantasy, it is also notoriously difficult to read cold due to its archaic style and dizzying number of characters.
Having lived in Middle-earth for over two decades, Serkis brings a profound understanding of the material. His pacing and emphasis showcase a deep respect for the source text. The Production: A Technical Feat In interviews, Serkis explained that he approaches the
No performance is without its detractors. A few listeners noted that Serkis’s pacing could feel "very slow" compared to the briskness of the original text. There are also isolated complaints regarding the audio production level—specifically regarding the dynamic range where whispered sections feel too quiet, though these are very much in the minority compared to the overwhelming praise.
As with any major Tolkien release, fan reactions have been a spectrum of emotion. The reception has largely been positive, but not without nuance.